The Label That Lingers
"You're too nice to lead".
Maybe you've heard it directly. Maybe it was phrased differently - too soft, too quiet, too emotional. Whatever the words, the message was the same: your way of leading wasn't enough.
And so you tried to adjust. Toughen up. Speak louder. Push harder. Put on the mask of certainty, even when it didn't fit.
But here's the truth that rarely gets named: you were never "too nice" to lead. You were under-supported.
The Myth Of Toughness
Somewhere along the way, leadership became equated with dominance.
The loudest voice. The quickest decision. The sharpest edge.
But what happens when your strength isn't in being forceful? When your natural instincts lean toward listening, noticing, and caring?
Traditional leadership models tend to frame those traits as liabilities. But in reality, they're foundations.
Because sensitivity isn't softness.
Empathy isn't weakness.
And kindness doesn't make you incapable.
They're what help teams trust, align, and sustain performance.
What's Really Missing
If you've been told your empathy is a problem, chances are the issue isn't your personality. It's the absence of support around it.
Here's what that support looks like in practice:
- Tools - frameworks that channel empathy into clarity and decisions.
- Language - ways of naming tensions without losing kindness.
- Boundaries - the ability to care deeply without carrying everything.
- Permission - to lead in ways that honour your strengths instead of masking them.
With those in place, your leadership shifts. You're not trying to act tougher. You're leading truer.
The Reframe
When people call you "too nice", what they often mean is that they don't yet see how kindness and authority can live together.
But they can.
Empathy doesn't dilute authority. It deepens it.
Sensitivity doesn't derail leadership. It steadies it.
Being "nice" doesn't mean you're waiting to be walked over. It means you know how to walk with.
And in today's world, that's not just valuable - it's essential.
My Gentle Reminder
If you've ever questioned whether your way of leading is "enough", remember this: you don't need a personality transplant.
You need a leadership model that fits. One that supports the kind of presence you already bring. One that recognises empathy not as a weakness to be corrected, but as a strength to be cultivated.
Because you're not too quiet.
You're not too emotional.
You're not too anything.
You're simply overdue for a way of leading that feels like yours.
Want to receive our latest blog posts directly to your mailbox?
