The Accountability Myth
"We need to hold people accountable".
It's one of the most common statements in leadership conversations.
It surfaces when metrics dip.
When deadlines slip.
When engagement starts to stall.
Accountability becomes the quick fix. The rallying cry. The level leaders pull when performance feels shaky.
But here's the truth: accountability on its own doesn't drive performance.
At least, not the kind that lasts.
The Missing Foundation
Before accountability, there's something else.
Something quieter.
Something teams often don't name, but always feel.
Safety.
The kind of safety that allows someone to say:
- "I don't know".
- "I made a mistake".
- "I'm stuck".
Without fear of blame.
Without fear of judgment.
Without fear of silence.
Why Safety Matters More Than Pressure
High performance isn't built through pressure alone.
It's built through permission.
Permission to be seen.
Permission to be human.
Permission to be honest, especially when it's hard.
Without that foundation, "accountability" risks becoming control. A culture of compliance rather than commitment. A cycle of fear rather than growth.
What We See In Teams
In our team development work, we've seen this pattern play out again and again:
- A leader doubles down on accountability, and the team's creativity shrinks.
- A manager enforces stricter deadlines, and mistakes get hidden rather than solved.
- A team culture praises resilience, but penalises vulnerability.
And yet, when safety is prioritised?
Performance doesn't weaken.
It deepens.
Because people aren't spending their energy protecting themselves. They're investing it in the work.
Reframing Accountability
Accountability isn't the enemy. It matters.
But accountability without safety isn't leadership.
It's control.
And control might deliver short-term compliance, but it doesn't create long-term performance.
The leaders who understand this - who create the conditions where safety and accountability coexist - don't just drive results.
They build teams that are resilient, resourceful, and ready to rise to the challenges ahead.
Want to receive our latest blog posts directly to your mailbox?
